The Circular Bioeconomy Alliance has brought 14 food businesses and retailers, including Nestlé, Danone, Mars, McDonald’s, Waitrose, Marks & Spencer and Lidl GB, into a new Regen Compact. Signatories commit to embed regenerative agriculture in their operations and to report progress each year against five principles, one of which is transparency.
That is welcome. It also exposes a problem the sector has not solved: regenerative agriculture data. Without evidence from each supplier farm, a pledge to farm differently is hard to prove.
A pledge is easy to sign and hard to evidence
The Compact does not set common metrics. Instead, the European Alliance for Regenerative Agriculture is to benchmark corporate actions independently against established principles. Benchmarking actions is a start, but buyers, investors and auditors ask about outcomes: what changed on each farm, and what it did to emissions and soil.
That question lands on procurement and sustainability teams, and through them on farmers.
The scale problem sits with the farmer
Take Waitrose, one of the signatories. According to Green Retail World, it aims for all of its more than 2,000 UK farmers and growers to adopt nature-friendly practices by 2030, and it funds independent soil, biodiversity and water assessments on around 100 farms.
Detailed assessments on a sample of farms are valuable. They do not scale to every supplier. Nestlé’s chief financial officer put it plainly: “Farmers cannot make this shift alone.” The same is true of the paperwork. A farmer supplying a processor, a retailer and a farm scheme can be asked for the same figures three times, in three formats.
Averages cannot show regenerative progress
Many food companies still estimate farm emissions in their Scope 3 (supply chain) inventory from regional or national averages. An average does not move when one farm cuts fertilizer, reseeds a pasture or changes its herd. The improvement happens, but it stays invisible in the numbers.
To show regenerative progress, a supply chain needs farm-level data, collected the same way every year and checked before it counts.
What farm-level data looks like in practice
This is the problem we built VSAg to solve. Farmers complete a video-guided survey on their phone, with each question explained and answers saved offline until there is signal. An adviser checks the answers and evidence before the farm counts. Each farm gets a whole-farm footprint and an action plan, and can reuse its answers for other schemes.
On the manufacturer side, the portal tracks progress across every supplier farm and rolls the results into one supply chain emissions view. Dairy and sugarcane are live today, and the approach works for any farm product.
Three questions to ask before the first annual report
For any food, dairy or drinks business with a regenerative commitment, Compact signatory or not, three questions are worth taking to the board. Can we show change on each supplier farm, not just a sample? Is that data checked before it reaches our report? And does collecting it make life easier for farmers, or harder?
If the honest answer to any of them is no, the first annual report is the place it shows. Talk to us about building the farm data before then.
Annual reporting under the Compact puts pressure on signatories to show what changed on supplier farms. Verified data from each farm, collected the same way every year, is what turns a pledge into a result.